So, what do the Football Association laws say?
Law 5 provides for: “It is permissible to help the referee the video in the event of a” clear and clear error “or” a serious incident “regarding: the goal/no goal, a penalty kick/no penalty, the direct red card (not the second caution), a wrong identity when the referee warns or the wrong player sends the procedure team.”
I read a message on social media from the English Premier League matches: “The referee's invitation was a free kick for Manchester United with Bayindir, which is considered to control the ball before Rogers acquired.
“A whistle was detonated by the referee before the ball entered the goal, and therefore the accident was not reviewed by VAR.”
Captain Villa John McGin, speaking with TNT SPORTS, admitted to winning, but said the decision not to give the goal “incredible”.
He added: “Everyone wanted the right decisions when VAR was executed. You watch the Rakhbi game … even if the referee had tried a wrong experience, it was vetoed.
“It is very difficult to take it, especially when the influence on us – as a club and a team – is very big. If you are at this stage 1-0 and all you need is a point to reach the Champions League, this is costly.
“The ruling did not really know what he was saying. It is a young judgment that raised very quickly. Maybe we can look at the presence of more experienced rulers.”
Law 12 stipulates that a goalkeeper is considered to control the ball in hand when:
-
The ball between the hands or between the hand and any surface or by touching it with any part of the hands or arms, unless the ball returns to the goalkeeper or the goalkeeper
-
Hold the ball in the outstretched open hand
-
Her liar on the ground or throwing it into the air
BBC Match of the Day Pundits Alan Shearer and Michael Richards agreed with Aston Villa, that Bayindir did not control the ball.
“You will be completely ready if you are Aston Villa and she is right,” said former England striker.
“It is a mistake and the judgment explodes very early so that VAR does not interfere. A big mistake when looking at the repercussions.
“The goalkeeper is achieving, and it never controls the ball. Morgan Rogers has all the right to get the ball. I understand anger, I really do it.”
“It is howl,” Richards, former defender Richards, added.
“He made a mistake, as simple, and the problem was that the reference was early that he could not go to Var.
“For Aston Villa is very close, it is not good enough. Referees make mistakes, we know they are doing it, but he just needed to calm.”
